How cute are these Thanksgiving Finger Puppets? Create the puppet body by wrapping your finger with a pipe cleaner. Glue a pompom onto the top for a head and decorate it with two googly eyes. For the Pilgrim, spiral a black pipe cleaner into a hat. Give the Indian a headband with a bent pipe-cleaner feather in the back. For the turkey, bend striped pipe cleaners in half to look like feathers and glue them into a fan-shaped tail.