Very true, just cause I don't talk to you about it doesn't mean I don't know about it. I'd like to add, I will not always talk about things that have to do with other people in my life, because it doesn't relate to my relationship with you. Not to be purposefully or maniplulatively reticent; just the way my brain is wired.
And Scorpio stands alone. We can not be generally categorized as either of these things. Due to our cognitive abilities, we carefully weigh out our decisions based on what we think the consequences/rewards of our actions will be and whether or not the consequences are worth the risk
If you care about us, we give our all. We'll give you anything and everything we can. Defend you fiercely. Love you like family. But, If you turn on us you will, flat out, cease to exist. No consideration is given to you. Done.