"NO BUT DO YOU WANT TO HEAR MY THEORY FOR THIS SCENE This doesn’t comply with the books, I realize, but it doesn’t exactly not comply either. Why..." follow the link and READ THE THEORY OMG UT BLEW MY MIND
I'm one of those people who is still annoyed about that tiny but in a way significant detail. It makes Dumbledore more eccentric and off his rocker than he really was. It bothers me, and it always will. If that makes me a crazy HP fan, then so be it.